Frequently Asked Questions

General & Process Questions

Question 1

What exactly is a property tax grievance?

+

A grievance is a formal challenge to the "Fair Market Value" that Nassau County has assigned to your property. If we can prove the County's valuation is higher than what your home is actually worth, or higher than similar homes on your block, the Assessment Review Commission (ARC) can lower your assessment, which reduces your future tax bills.

Question 2

Can my property taxes go up if I file a grievance?

+

No. By law, the Assessment Review Commission (ARC) cannot increase your assessment as a result of filing a grievance. The outcome will either be a reduction or no change. There is zero risk to your current assessment by challenging it.

Question 3

Do I need to allow a home inspection?

+

In the vast majority of cases, no. Our process is driven by Curated Market Intelligence and neighborhood equity data. Unless you are claiming massive structural damage that requires a specialized "Cost-to-Cure" argument, a physical inspection is rarely required to win a reduction.

Question 4

Do I need a lawyer to file a property tax grievance in Nassau County?

+

No. Nassau County's Assessment Review Commission (ARC) allows any homeowner to file their own grievance through the AROW (Assessment Review on the Web) portal. There is no legal requirement to hire an attorney.

Why you should choose us (FairValue Tax Appeal) over a lawyer:

  • Keep more of Your Savings: Traditional firms typically take 40% to 50% of your first year's savings as a fee. With our Evidence Pack or Filed For You option, you pay a flat fee and keep 100% of any tax savings.
  • Instant Professionalism: You don't have to wait for a law clerk to return your call. Generate a professional-grade evidence report in 10 seconds and file immediately.

The FairValue Technology Advantage

Question 5

How is FairValue different from a traditional tax firm?

+

FairValue is built around data, AI-assisted analysis, and flexible pricing options. Instead of reviewing a small sample of properties, we analyze nearly every Nassau County Class 1 home, verified comparable sales, assessment records, historical appeal outcomes, and neighborhood patterns to help homeowners understand whether their assessment may be too high.

  • Comprehensive property data: We compare your home against 340,000+ Nassau Class 1 properties, not just a handful of manually selected examples.
  • AI-powered analysis: Our models estimate appeal strength, potential assessment reduction, fair market value, and the evidence most likely to support your challenge.
  • Flexible pricing: Homeowners can choose a flat-fee Evidence Pack, flat-fee Filed For You service, or a Full-Service Appeal with success-based pricing.

For our Full-Service Appeal option, the transparency is especially important: our contingency fee is based on your actual first-year property tax savings, not an estimate derived from the reduction in assessment. Because a successful appeal is reflected in future School Tax and General Tax bills, the actual savings are not known immediately. For example, for an appeal filed in 2027, the first year's tax savings typically cannot be calculated accurately until the General Tax bill is issued in January 2029.

Many property tax appeal firms estimate tax savings using the previous year's tax rates or other estimated rates and bill clients months, or even a year, earlier. Those estimates may be close, but they may not match the homeowner's actual tax savings.

At FairValue, we would rather wait than guess. We calculate our fee using your actual tax bills, making every charge clear, transparent, and easy to verify.

Question 6

How does your "10-Second Analysis" work?

+

Our system has already pre-processed the entire Nassau County database. When you enter your address, we instantly cross-reference your home's SBL (Section-Block-Lot) against our database of 20,000+ verified recent sales and local assessment floors. This allows us to give you a surgical estimate of your potential savings in real-time.

Question 7

What is an "AI-Powered Evidence Narrative"?

+

Data alone doesn't win cases; the logic does. For Evidence Pack users, our AI acts as a professional consultant. It translates raw market data into a dispassionate, legal-grade narrative using standard terminology like SBL, Grade, and CDU. It selects only the most persuasive comparables and omits "noisy" data that could hurt your case, ensuring the ARC reviewer sees a clear, objective reason for a reduction.

Deadlines & Timelines (Nassau Specific)

Question 8

What is the timeline for 2027 tax grievance year (or 2028/2029 tax year)?

+

The timeline for the 2028/2029 tax year in Nassau County follows a specific cycle where you challenge the value nearly 18 months before the tax bills arrive. Here is the essential schedule:

1. The Filing Period (January - March 2027)

  • January 2, 2027: The Tentative Assessment Roll is published, and the filing window opens.
  • March 1, 2027: The standard deadline to file your application with the Assessment Review Commission (ARC).
  • Note: This date is sometimes extended to end of March, but aim for March 1st to be safe. FairValue will update this page when the county confirms the official deadline.

2. The Review Phase (March 2027 - March 2028)

  • Ongoing: You may receive a settlement offer (stipulation) from the county during this time.
  • March 31, 2028: This is the deadline for ARC to issue final determinations on the grievances filed in early 2027.

3. The Judicial Appeal (April 2028)

  • April 30, 2028: Typical deadline to file a Small Claims Assessment Review (SCAR) petition. This is the appeal phase that involves a hearing officer.

4. When You See the Savings (2028 - 2029)

  • October 2028: Savings reflect on your School Tax bill.
  • January 2029: Savings reflect on your General (County/Town) Tax bill.

Summary Tip: The most important date for you right now is January 2, 2027. That is when the window opens to protect your savings for the 2028/2029 tax year. If you miss that March deadline, you cannot challenge that specific year's taxes later.

Question 9

If I sign up today for the 2027 window, when will I actually see my taxes go down?

+

Nassau County operates on a long cycle. A successful 2027 grievance will impact your 2028/29 School Tax Bill (typically arriving in October 2028) and your 2029 General Tax Bill (arriving in January 2029). This is why starting early is critical.

Fees & Service Paths

Question 10

What is the difference between Evidence Pack, Filed For You, and Full-Service Appeal?

+
  • Evidence Pack (Early-Bird Rate: $99, increases to $149 once the County filing window opens): You receive our AI-generated evidence report and file the grievance yourself via the County's AROW portal. You keep 100% of the savings.
  • Filed For You (Early-Bird Rate: $199, increases to $249 once the County filing window opens): We prepare and file your Nassau County grievance package for one flat fee. There is no contingency fee and you keep 100% of any savings.
  • Full-Service Appeal (Early-Bird Rate: 25% of the first year's savings, increases to 30% once the County filing window opens): We handle the end-to-end process: filing strategy, authorization, deadlines, review responses, hearing preparation, and negotiation. If we don't win a reduction, you pay $0.

Question 11

Are there any hidden costs?

+

No. Evidence Pack and Filed For You are one-time flat-fee options. Full-Service Appeal has no upfront cost, and if there is no reduction, you pay $0. There are no "processing fees" or "appraisal fees" tucked into our contracts.

Property Specifics

Question 12

I just bought my house. Should I still grieve?

+

Absolutely. If your purchase price was lower than the County's market value, your own sale is the strongest evidence possible. Our engine will use your recent closing and anchor it against the 20,000+ verified sales in our database to ensure the County equalizes your value immediately.

Question 13

My home is in poor condition (needs a roof, windows, etc.). Does that help my case?

+

Yes. We use "Cost-to-Cure" logic. When you provide details about deferred maintenance, our AI integrates these defects as direct negative adjustments to your home's value. We speak the language of "Functional Obsolescence" to prove to the ARC that your home is worth less than a renovated "peer" property.

Question 14

What if I live in a Condo or Co-op?

+

Condos and Co-ops in Nassau are valued differently (based on income-producing potential). Our current Precision Prediction Model is optimized for Class 1 Residential properties (Single-family, 2-family, etc.). If you own a residential home, our data is tailored specifically for you.

Ownership & Annual Strategies

Question 15

I am in contract or planning to sell my home. What happens to the grievance?

+

The tax grievance is tied to the Section-Block-Lot (SBL) of the property, not the specific owner. If you sell, the appeal moves forward with the house. Having an active, data-backed grievance can actually be a selling point, as it proves to potential buyers that you are proactively lowering the future tax burden. If you are the buyer, our 10-Second Analysis can immediately show you if the previous owner was over-assessed.

Question 16

I successfully reduced my taxes last year. Can I win again this year?

+

Yes, and you should try. Every January 2nd, the County releases a new "Tentative Assessment Roll." The market is dynamic, over 20,000 sales happen in Nassau every two years, and your neighbors' assessments are constantly shifting. Even if you won last year, a new "Equity Gap" may have opened up. Our engine re-scans the entire neighborhood every season to see if you can be "pushed" even lower toward the new Equity Floor.

Question 17

Why is it necessary to file every single year?

+

Nassau County assessments rarely stay stagnant. If your neighbors file and you don't, you may end up carrying a disproportionate share of the neighborhood tax burden. By filing annually, you ensure your home is always equalized with the lowest-assessed similar properties on your block. Our Live Neighborhood Tracking makes this easy by identifying new "Same-Street" evidence the moment it becomes available.

Question 18

My neighbor received a reduction, but I did not. Why?

+

Assessments are highly specific to the home's SBL, Grade, and Condition (CDU). Your neighbor may have had a different "structural grade" or specific defects that our Cost-to-Cure logic identified. This is exactly why we don't use generic neighborhood averages. We look at the specific data for your lot to find the unique "Equity Gap" that applies only to you.

Question 19

I just finished a renovation. Should I skip this year to avoid being 'noticed'?

+

The Assessment Review Commission (ARC) is legally barred from increasing your assessment just because you filed a grievance. While a major renovation increases market value, your "Equity" is still compared to the rest of the block. Our Precision Prediction Model can help determine if you are still over-assessed relative to other renovated homes in your area, ensuring you don't pay more than your fair share for those improvements.

Question 20

If I file through FairValue, do I still have to communicate with the County?

+
  • For Filed For You: No. We prepare and file your Nassau County grievance package and manage the filing workflow.
  • For Full-Service Appeal: No. We act as your authorized representative for the full appeal workflow, including ARC review responses, negotiation, and hearing preparation where needed.
  • For Evidence Pack: You remain the point of contact, but we provide you with the AI-Powered Narrative and the SBL-specific evidence you need. You simply upload our report to the County's portal, and the data does the talking for you.

Terms of Service ยท Privacy Policy ยท Back to Home